“A&E ‘struggling to cope with demand” ITV News
“I wonder if my neighbours wonder ‘why is this man calling the ambulance all the time?’” Edgar, 79
Over the past few months there have beena number of reports showing that A&E across the country is in crisis, stretched to breaking point with the increasing number of patients coming through their doors. Some of these patients are non-urgent cases, mistakenly advised to dial 999. There are other patients turning up who should be receiving care in the community but are not receiving support, or getting enough advice, from out-of- hours GPs.
But as the recent 24 Hours in A&E documentary, broadcast by Channel 4, demonstrated, loneliness and isolation are also adding to patient numbers and increasing use of health services.
The episode follows a number of patients including the wonderfully chatty Irena, a widow originally from Poland, and 79-year old Edgar, a retired architect suffering from asthma. Neither is – or should be – blamed for attending A&E. But neither have anyone else to turn to when struck with sudden ailments or worried about their health.
Talking to camera, Edgar explains that his asthma got worse after his wife died. Grieving, with no friends, church or family to help him, he says: “If something happens to me, there wouldn’t be anyone there…I’m lost”
Des, a Registrar at the King’s College Hospital A&E department where this documentary is filmed, , patiently treats Edgar’s physical symptoms and then addresses the emotional, calling a British Red Cross volunteer who arranges for a home visit for Edgar. Des later sums up why people who are very lonely turn to acute health services:
“Unfortunately, we see an awful lot of patients who are completely alone, living a very, very isolated life. In the middle of night, if you’re not feeling well – it’s a particularly dark and lonely place to be…”
Research demonstrates that lonely people are more likely to visit A&E than non-lonely individuals. Non-lonely people spend fewer days in hospital and have fewer outpatient appointments.
A GP’s experience
It is not just A&E that has to deal with the impact of isolation and loneliness on service use and budgets. Jonathan Tomlinson, a practising GP, campaigner and blogger, recently wrote an eloquent post titled ‘Loneliness’.
The post gives us two perspectives – a lonely and isolated patient called Joan, and the voice of her GP. The GP wonders if he is depriving patients with more pressing needs by seeing Joan so frequently: “Her appointments, almost double the average six per patient per year, feel like an indulgence.” He is frustrated by her minor ailments, and tries to not be brusque.
Joan is worried about wasting his time, recognises that she is desperately lonely but feels it is easier to talk about “being depressed” or “feeling tired” or “anything really apart from the fact that you’ve got nobody and you’re on your own.”
Research demonstrates that lonely people are more likely to visit their GP, use more medication and have a higher incidence of falls.
What can we do?
Tackling loneliness to reduce demand on A&E, GP and care services is not just about saving money. It is about people receiving the best possible care, at the best time, and in the best place for them. NHS employees provide compassionate care and demonstrate great patience and empathy. But there are better ways – for both the NHS and the patients – to support those who are feeling lonely.
As Des the Registrar explains: “I find it difficult that there is an aspect of my patient’s care that I can’t sort out. Because that’s why I’m here, to sort out these issues…I’d love to make everything absolutely fantastic, but life is not like that.”
Last month, Community Care Magazine published a call-to-arms from Sherry Malik, Director of Children and Adults at Hounslow Borough Council, for GPs and social workers to work together to address loneliness “at the root of the problem”.
Rather than capping the number of GP appointments, she argues, policy makers should be encouraging GPs to work with social workers to develop social prescribing that will help isolated individuals build relationships. She also argues that this partnership can develop more creative and person-centred care that builds confidence and helps tackle loneliness by reconnecting people to their community.
This is just one of a number of solutions. 24 Hours in A&E shows another by ending with the news that Edgar has met people and made new friends through the British Red Cross services in his area. This is what he needs, alongside some low-level support to manage his asthma.
Take action now!
Regular readers of this blog will know that over the past year we have been supporting local groups and individuals to lobby their health and wellbeing board (new forums for senior health and care officials) to tackle loneliness in older age with our Loneliness Harms Health campaign.
There are 152 health and wellbeing boards across England, and each has to publish a ‘Joint Health and Wellbeing Strategy’. This is a strategic plan for addressing health, public health and social care needs in a particular area.
The Joint Health and Wellbeing Strategy can have a significant influence on the future of local services as it makes recommendations for how resources and money should be allocated in a local area. The Campaign to End Loneliness believes that loneliness and isolation should be prioritised in these strategies to make sure services and activities that keep people connected are protected.
To find out what your local health and wellbeing board plans to do to tackle loneliness (if anything), visit: www.campaigntoendloneliness.org.uk/ignoringthehealthrisks
You can help make sure that those responsible for health and wellbeing services in your area are aware of the health risks of loneliness, and its impact on service use, by getting involved in Loneliness Harms Health. For information, hints, tips and templates to help you, take a look at our campaign pages.